Sandra Tuttle
Phone
305-923-9161
Website
IslandWelcomeRealEstate.com
Office Name
Island Welcome Real Estate
Office Phone
305-923-9161
Address
24437 Overseas Hwy
Summerland Key,
FL
33042
Featured Listings
New Listing · 7 hours
$799,000
75 Lobstertail Road
Big Pine Key, FL 33043
#619333
New Listing
$799,000
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
75
Street Name
Lobstertail
Subdivision
Cahill Pines & Palms (30.0)
Key/Island
Big Pine Key
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 9:36pm, April 2, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
$719,000
10877 Overseas Highway Unit 81
Marathon, FL 33050
#615004
Active
$719,000
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
10877
Street Name
Overseas
Subdivision
Ocean Isles Fishing (52.5)
Key/Island
Marathon
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 10:56am, April 2, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
New Listing · 1 day
$3,500,000
1083 Labat Lane
Cudjoe Key, FL 33042
#619314
New Listing
$3,500,000
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
1083
Street Name
Labat
Subdivision
Cutthroat Harbor Est (23.0)
Key/Island
Cudjoe Key
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 7:24pm, April 1, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
Floor Plan
$1,195,000
29534 Geraldine Street
Big Pine Key, FL 33043
#619184
Active
$1,195,000
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
29534
Street Name
Geraldine
Subdivision
Big Pine Shores (29.0)
Key/Island
Big Pine Key
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 9:26am, April 1, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
New Listing · 2 days
$2,295,000
937 Gulf Drive
Summerland Key, FL 33042
#619294
New Listing
$2,295,000
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
937
Street Name
Gulf
Subdivision
Summerland Cove Isle (25.5)
Key/Island
Summerland Key
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 9:38pm, March 31, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
Floor Plan
$3,695,000
680 Elma Avenue
Big Pine Key, FL 33043
#617430
Active
$3,695,000
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
680
Street Name
Elma
Subdivision
Piney Point Sub (29.5)
Key/Island
Big Pine Key
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 7:25pm, March 31, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
$714,000
4039 Egret Lane
Big Torch Key, FL 33042
#618961
Active
$714,000
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
4039
Street Name
Egret
Subdivision
Torchwood West (25.5)
Key/Island
Big Torch Key
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 2:48am, March 29, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
Floor Plan
$1,150,000
110 Doubloon Lane
Cudjoe Key, FL 33042
#619225
Active
$1,150,000
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
110
Street Name
Doubloon
Subdivision
Cutthroat Harbor Est (23.0)
Key/Island
Cudjoe Key
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 7:02pm, March 26, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
Floor Plan
$599,000
27940 Lobster Tail Trail
Little Torch Key, FL 33042
#616963
Active
$599,000
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
27940
Street Name
Lobster Tail
Subdivision
Coral Shores Estates (28.0)
Key/Island
Little Torch Key
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 9:59am, March 20, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
Floor Plan
$749,500
360 W Shore Drive
Summerland Key, FL 33042
#617776
Active
$749,500
Side
Mile Marker
Unit #
Street #
360
Street Name
Shore
Subdivision
Summerland Key Cove (25.0)
Key/Island
Summerland Key
Bank Owned
Potential Short Sale
Sold Date
Last Modified: 1:55pm, March 19, 2026
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
IDX
List Office Name: Island Welcome Real Estate
Featured Searches